Is EMF an effective anti-fouling technology?

Leader

Challenge 

Mineral scaling and biological fouling processes decrease the efficiency of reverse osmosis (RO) desalination and often require costly measures to mitigate, such as the introduction of chemical antiscalants, biocides, or physical pretreatment by microfiltration (MF) or ultrafiltration (UF) membranes.

A number of electromagnetic based non-chemical water treatment technologies have been commercialised but their main application has not been in the prevention of RO membrane fouling. Many of these technologies have not been embraced by the membrane desalination industry due in part to inconsistent results in early trials, exaggerated claims and the lack of scientific transparency regarding mechanisms of action.

The anti-scaling and anti-biofouling activities are incompletely understood but presumed to derive from an applied electromagnetic field (EMF) that varies in amplitude and frequency. It is hypothesised that the secondary EMF changes the surface electrical potential of suspended colloids and also causes damage to the cytoplasmic membranes of bacteria.

Investigation

Investigate the EMF method of action by examining the effects of two commercial pulsed EMF units on bacterial growth, mineral scaling and on “magnetic memory” (or water structure).

Outcomes

Two commercial units were characterised in terms of their frequencies and waveforms and static operation, which was adopted to give a worst case scenario and to maximise the sensitivity of the experiments. The results demonstrate that exposure to EMF radiation can both stimulate and inhibit bacterial growth depending upon the time of exposure and the specific waveform used. However, it was found that the observed inhibition of growth, whilst significant, is minimal and is not sufficient to justify the claims of the manufacturers. Studies looking at manufacturers’ claims that EMF effect reduces chemical scaling in a RO feed stream revealed no convincing evidence.

Future Direction

The baseline effects of the two commercial EMF units have now been determined and the team will continue this work by building an EMF device and repeating the experiments to confirm the findings. Further investigation into the water structure/clustering studies are needed to compare the effects of different durations of EMF treatment. Different impurities, such as iron, will also be tested to determine the effects of various compounds on “water memory”.

Partner


 

Total Value: $328,900 (cash and in-kind contributions)

Principal Investigator: Dr Thomas Yeager

Title: Evaluation of non-chemical pulsed power technology as an antifouling pretreatment for reverse osmosis desalination membranes

Length: 31 months

Personnel: 6 collaborators contributing 1.4 FTE

Further Information

FR3 VU Yeager (Pulsed-Power) Summary Poster

Project Summary Poster – EMF

WP-Backgrounds Lite by InoPlugs Web Design and Juwelier Schönmann 1010 Wien